Bay Street Theater | Melissa Manchester

“Ma Cagney” is Stealing Hearts at Bay Street!

The reviews are in, and our favorite Grammy winner is officially dazzling audiences out in the Hamptons! Critics are falling in love with Melissa’s heartwarming performance as "Ma Cagney" in Cagney: The Musical at the Bay Street Theater. See what the buzz is all about!

Melissa Manchester Joins the Cast of “Cagney the Musical”

lenaringstad2026-07-02T21:35:22-07:00April 16th, 2026|Categories: News|Tags: Bay Street Theater, Cagney the Musical, Ma Cagney, Melissa Manchester, Musical Theater, New York, Sag Harbor, Summer 2026|

Melissa is returning to the stage this summer, joining the cast of Cagney the Musical at the Bay Street Theater in Sag Harbor, New York. Taking on the role of Ma Cagney, Melissa portrays the steadfast "touchstone" and mother of the legendary Hollywood tough guy and dancer, James Cagney.